
I avoided All-Star Batman & Robin, The Boy Wonder for years.
After The Dark Knight Returns and Batman: Year One, Frank Miller had earned enormous goodwill with me. Then I read The Dark Knight Strikes Again and watched most of that goodwill flee Gotham at high speed.
So when Miller teamed with Jim Lee for a new Batman series in 2005, I passed. The furious reviews, infamous dialogue, and glacial publishing schedule only reinforced that decision.
Eventually curiosity won.
And, surprisingly, I didn’t hate it.
The key is accepting that this is not our Batman. Miller’s Gotham is a warped, cynical reflection of the DC Universe, and its Batman is a product of that world: arrogant, unstable, brutal, and absolutely convinced that referring to himself as the “goddamn Batman” is something normal people do.
I also can’t help feeling that the modern Absolute DC Universe — with its darker, harsher reinterpretations of familiar heroes — owes at least a little of its storytelling DNA to All-Star Batman & Robin. Miller was already experimenting with the idea of taking the recognizable shape of the DC Universe, stripping away much of its optimism, and seeing what crawled out of the shadows.
Oddly enough, that makes the book work better for me as a prequel to The Dark Knight Returns than The Dark Knight Strikes Again works as its sequel.
My biggest problem is the artwork — which feels ridiculous to say because Jim Lee’s pages are gorgeous. They’re simply too polished and heroic for Miller’s grimy, dystopian story. The words say Sin City while the pictures say blockbuster DC superhero comic, and the two are constantly wrestling for control of the page.
All-Star Batman & Robin is messy, excessive, frequently absurd, and definitely not for everyone.
But it is never boring.
And sometimes that’s enough to make me turn the page.

